Monday, May 7, 2012

Judge DeSalvo

If I were the Judge I would almost definitely rule in Anna's favor. Its a case that deals with human rights. Anna as a human being has natural rights. She should have to go with a surgery if she doesn't want to. I understand Sara's natural concern as a mother. She wants the best for Kate and everyone in the book know and understands Anna probably wont be harmed in the surgeries but its the fact she has no say in anything. Campbell is looking at the small chance that she could be harmed and that no one actually cares about Anna. The doctor constantly says that chances are small she could be harmed but with all of the surgeries she could be harmed greatly. All perspectives have their points and justifications.